Playability: 4
Very fun to play! although the cities of the americans are mostly useless.
Balance: 4
Not too hard but a little easy, the ships made it easier but the attrition harder.
Creativity: 4
I saw this kind of scenario some times now, although you did it your own way. there was scripting missing and some triggers to make it interesting.
Map Design: 3
It didint really look like france, and there was too much useless sea, also the american cities werent necessary.
Story/Instructions: 3
The story is known to all and the instructions simple.
Additional Comments:
Aditional changes made it better.