Playability: 2
Was far too easy to win, not enough of challenge.
Balance: 2
USA starts out with too many forces. Japan don't even have a city. Not enough units for Japan.
Creativity: 2
Nothing original here. At least units were setup in formation.
Map Design: 1
Just 2 islands, not any oil patches. Japan don't have access to any forests or mountains.
Story/Instructions: 1
Nothing here.
Additional Comments:
Could be better by starting out Japan with more units and not alot of resources. Then US could startout with alot of resources and not much units. They would have to buildup and then attack, like they done in history.