Playability: 4
Nice but the British army rarely attacks
Balance: 5
Very difficult
Creativity: 4
Well you tried your best in the trench warfare
Map Design: 4
Standard
Story/Instructions: 5
Nice story, especially the red baron thing
Additional Comments:
Overall a very nice scenario
StormEye
Posted on 04/11/05 @ 08:18 AM
Rating
4.0
Breakdown
Playability
3.0
Balance
4.0
Creativity
5.0
Map Design
4.0
Story/Instructions
4.0
Playability: 3
The scenario is good, but the british should attack and they rarelly attack and some units i build have slow motion...
Balance: 4
Good but a bit hard, maybe if the british attaked it became more easy!
Creativity: 5
Excellent story and historical points!!
Map Design: 4
Like LGP said, standart map... nedded more goodies!!!
Story/Instructions: 4
Good story, needed a bit more instructions durring the game!
Additional Comments:
King Walker
Posted on 04/19/05 @ 09:20 AM
Rating
3.6
Breakdown
Playability
3.0
Balance
4.0
Creativity
4.0
Map Design
3.0
Story/Instructions
4.0
Playability: 3
(I found that is very trilling to play this scenario, i have only 2 things to say that you may correct: first you should correct the enemie attack timing, they should attack more often and secound, i understand your idea of making those units more slow than normal, but it dosent look very real this way.)
Balance: 4
(A bit hard with those units fire-power, but is well balanced, done a nice work with the dificulty levels)
Creativity: 4
(Since this is a historical scenario i dont have much to say, but is the best way to a new designer creator, good job here!)
Map Design: 3
(You could put more things in the map, like trees and goddies, the eyecanddie is important.)
Story/Instructions: 4
(Good instructions details, the red barron!! nice!! but when the enemie toke so much time to attack, sometimes i feel lost!)
Additional Comments:
For a starter scenario is very good work, if you keep this way you should became a very good scenario designer!!
Guitar
Posted on 05/16/05 @ 02:57 PM
Rating
4.0
Breakdown
Playability
5.0
Balance
5.0
Creativity
4.0
Map Design
2.0
Story/Instructions
4.0
Playability: 5
Very playable, and realistic, tanks kill infantry in no time!
Balance: 5
Good, very good.
Creativity: 4
It has lots of creative effort, idea is very orginal. But map can be much better.
Map Design: 2
Poor, altough it can depict the trench war very good, you must place some trees and details to make it lots of better
Story/Instructions: 4
Orginal context, good instuction.
Additional Comments:
Once the map design is improved a bit, I definately want it in my WWI CTW!