this is a ww1 scenario of the battle of jutland you are the Great Britain and have an army north of denmark which you must use to stop the defend the remander of demark-your ally-and capture the rest of it. you also have a navy that you need to use to destory the enermies navy.
Playability: 3
It played OK. not a lot here to do.
Balance: 3
The naval balance is pretty good, but the land forces seem one-sided for the friendlies.
Creativity: 2
Maybe as a fictional account it would have been creative, but for historical accounts it was inaccurate.
Map Design: 2
Lots of water a few cites and buildings. Not much else.
Story/Instructions: 2
A little given here, although it's not historically correct. None given otherwise.
Additional Comments:
It's fine to fictionalize historical accounts, but then it shouldn't be advertised as historical. I was expecting progress as you made new scenarios, but you seem to be content with minor works.