This is the same as my old scenario however this time there are no tanks and you gain navy reinforcements after 50s. the enermys navy is alot bigger and you only get your army to invade denmark when the enermy's navy is destroyed.
Playability: 4
(No compliants and no special instruction)
Balance: 4
(Pretty much even steven here, seemed a fair fight.)
Creativity: 2
(Even-Steven hurts you here, too even, I never felt challenged, and quite frankly I am a weak naval tactician. I had 5 units left when I won on the first try. The site has multiple skill levels, you need to try an accomodate all players. Not so easy. You didn't highlight an Action or key point of this historical battle in the scenario, just water and ships.)
Map Design: 3
(You did an admirable job fixing the discrepancies from the first scenario. I commend you there, BUT, you just added some ships. )
Story/Instructions: 3
(This by no means the History Channel, but you got to make an effort to get the player interested in playing the scenario. Your time is also important, so your efforts reflect in the storyline from the view of the player. No story why should I play? I know you've seen comments "What's This?". )
Additional Comments: Chris, this was a good scenario overall, I didn't want to review, but, know one seems to be interested in setting an initial scale for you to work from, which is really difficult for the writer to attempt other scenario ideas. After creating the original Switchblade scenario, there was over a 100 downloads before probed69 chimed in to give me some constructive points and encouragement. So I hope my comments will help and encourage you to make more scenarios in the future. I know you will produce some entertaining scenarios in the future. Keep at it...marce